Worst Insurance Companies in South Africa

Worst Insurance Companies in South Africa

Finding a reliable insurance company in South Africa is not always easy, especially as more consumers grow frustrated with poor service, rising costs, and unfulfilled promises. Recent studies reveal that customer loyalty in the short-term insurance industry is falling sharply. Many companies are struggling to explain their value and deliver consistent service across all areas of their business. According to Consulta’s latest survey, South African policyholders are becoming more critical and less forgiving, particularly when it comes to service delivery, value for money, and the quality of claim handling.

Consumers expect fair treatment, transparency, and quick responses when they file claims or seek assistance. Unfortunately, not all insurers meet these standards. Complaints about delayed claim payouts, confusing policy terms, and unhelpful customer service have become common across the country. This growing dissatisfaction has made it clear that many insurers are failing to deliver the reliability and peace of mind they promise in their marketing.

While a few companies still manage to earn trust through strong communication and efficient claims processes, several have developed poor reputations that continue to push customers away. In this article, we take a closer look at some of the worst insurance companies in South Africa based on real customer feedback, industry performance, and satisfaction ratings.

READ ALSO: Top 5 Best Car Insurance Companies In South Africa

What Makes An Insurance Company Worst?

An insurance company is often considered one of the worst when it fails to meet customer expectations, provides poor service, and lacks transparency. Below are the main factors that contribute to a bad reputation:

• Hidden costs and unclear policies:

Some insurers advertise low premiums but include confusing terms or hidden charges. This lack of honesty leaves customers feeling deceived and disappointed.

• Poor communication:

Companies that fail to keep clients informed about policy updates, renewals, or claim progress create frustration and confusion. Clear, timely communication is essential for customer trust.

• Slow or unfair claims process:

Delayed payouts, excessive paperwork, and unfair claim rejections can make clients lose confidence in their insurer. Customers expect fast, fair, and transparent claims handling.

• Poor customer service:

Long waiting times, unhelpful agents, and rude responses reflect a lack of care and professionalism. When support is weak, customers quickly lose patience.

• Lack of accountability:

Insurers that refuse to correct their mistakes or avoid resolving issues show little concern for their clients’ needs or satisfaction.

• Negative reviews and frequent complaints:

A constant stream of bad feedback from customers often signals deeper operational or ethical problems within the company.

Worst Insurance Companies in South Africa

When it comes to short-term insurance in South Africa, not every company meets customer expectations. Many policyholders have shared concerns about poor service, delayed claims, and a lack of transparency.

According to the 2019 OSTI Report, the following insurers were among the most complained-about insurance companies in South Africa, based on the number of complaints per thousand claims and the percentage of cases resolved through enforcement:

• New National Insurance:

10.2 complaints per thousand claims, with 2.09% resolved through enforcement.

• Dial Direct:

5.6 complaints per thousand claims, with 2.11% resolved through enforcement.

• Oakhurst Insurance:

5.1 complaints per thousand claims, with 2.16% resolved through enforcement.

• Budget Insurance:

4.7 complaints per thousand claims, with 1.52% resolved through enforcement.

• Absa Insurance:

4.5 complaints per thousand claims, with 1.48% resolved through enforcement.

• King Price Insurance:

4.4 complaints per thousand claims, with 1.73% resolved through enforcement.

• First for Women:

3.8 complaints per thousand claims, with 2.11% resolved through enforcement.

• MiWay Insurance:

3.6 complaints per thousand claims, with 1.60% resolved through enforcement.

How To Choose The Best Insurance Companies in South Africa

Choosing the best insurance company in South Africa is about more than finding the cheapest premium. It is about selecting a provider that offers reliable coverage, great service, and clear communication. With so many options available, consider the following:

• Clear and honest communication:

A trustworthy insurer explains its policies in simple terms and avoids hidden costs. Before signing any contract, make sure you understand exactly what is covered and what is not.

• Claim efficiency and fairness:

The true test of an insurance company is how it handles claims. Choose one known for processing claims quickly, fairly, and without unnecessary delays.

• Financial strength:

An insurer’s financial stability is essential. A strong, stable company is more likely to honour claims and provide long-term reliability.

• Customer reviews and reputation:

Reading feedback from other policyholders gives insight into the company’s service quality. Consistent complaints about claims or poor communication can be warning signs.

• Flexible policy options:

The best insurers offer plans that suit different needs and budgets. Whether you are looking for car, home, or life insurance, flexibility helps you get the coverage that truly fits your situation.

• Reliable customer support:

Great service makes a big difference. Choose a company that responds quickly, communicates clearly, and genuinely helps when you need assistance.

FAQs: Worst Insurance Companies In South Africa

What Causes An Insurance Company To Be Considered One Of The Worst In South Africa?


• An Insurer Often Earns A Bad Name When It Fails To Deliver Quality Service, Delays Claim Payments, Or Uses Confusing And Unclear Policy Terms. Poor Customer Support, Hidden Charges, And Slow Responses To Complaints Also Lead To Customer Frustration.

How Can I Check If An Insurer Receives Many Complaints?

• 
You Can Review The Ombudsman For Short-Term Insurance (OSTI) Reports, Which List The Number Of Complaints Received Against Each Company Every Year. Reading Online Reviews And Feedback From Other Policyholders Can Also Give A Good Idea Of An Insurer’s Performance.

Which Insurance Companies Are Known For Having The Most Complaints?


• Based On The 2019 OSTI Report, Insurers Such As New National Insurance, Dial Direct, Oakhurst, Budget, Absa, King Price, First For Women, And MiWay Recorded The Highest Number Of Complaints In South Africa.

Does Receiving Complaints Automatically Mean An Insurance Company Is Bad?


• Not Necessarily. Some Companies Handle A Large Number Of Clients, So Higher Complaint Numbers Can Be Expected. What Truly Matters Is How The Insurer Responds To And Resolves Those Complaints.

How Can I Avoid Signing Up With A Bad Insurer?

• 
Take Time To Compare Different Companies, Read Verified Reviews, And Check The OSTI’s Complaint Statistics. Always Go Through Your Policy Terms Carefully And Make Sure The Company Communicates Clearly About Claims And Coverage.

What Can I Do If I Have A Problem With My Insurance Provider?


• Start By Contacting Your Insurer Directly To Resolve The Issue. If You Do Not Get A Fair Response, You Can Escalate The Matter To The Ombudsman For Short-Term Insurance (OSTI), Who Helps Settle Disputes Between Insurers And Customers.

Can An Insurance Company Improve Its Reputation After Bad Reviews?

• 
Yes. Some Insurers Take Negative Feedback Seriously And Work To Improve Claim Handling, Customer Communication, And Transparency. Over Time, Consistent Improvements Can Help Restore Customer Trust And Rebuild Their Image.

Visit the official website for more information. I hope the provided information is helpful. Share your thoughts below in the comment section.

RELATED LINKS